At Midnight all the Agents
I have just heard the new cover by My Chemical Romance of the magnificent Bob Dylan’s song Desolation Row. It is horrible.
It has been made as part of the Watchmen movie soundtrack, and I’m afraid it could be an example of what the movie will be. Desolation Row is a calm and almost mesmerizing song, with a beautiful melodic and nostalgic guitar chords and, off course, with the mellow voice of Dylan. It lasts more than eleven minutes and is full of literary and cultural meaningful references. On the other hand, the new cover is a little more than three minutes song that takes three and a half of the ten verses of the original (and do it with such a stupid criteria; the first two, then the one cited by Moore at the end of chapter one, and ends with… the end) and the music sounds just as any other song by a new-punk-emo-rock band (a lot of power chords played as frenetically as they can).
The deepness of the song has been totally diluted to make it more accessible to the big audience, especially to the average teenagers who are the target of the song, and I’m afraid, of the movie. Because of what, there’s a chance that it will be diluted too, turned into a superficial super-hero action movie, make the amazing characters, and their complex psychology into just superhero cartoons. Just as a great song has been turned into a noisy emo song.